Application Note AN043 [604844]

Application Note AN043

Small Size 2.4 GHz PCB antenna
By Audun Andersen

1 KEYWORDS

• CC25xx
• CC24xx
• CC2480
• PCB antenna
• USB dongle
• 2.4 GHz
• Inverted F Antenna

2 INTRODUCTION
The PCB antenna used on the CC2511
USB dongle reference design is described
in this application note. Even if the
antenna presented is for a USB dongle
design it can be used in all 2.4 GHz
designs, especially where small space is
required for the antenna.

This application note describes the
antenna dimensions, the RF performance and considerations for complying with
regulatory limits when using this design.

The suggested antenna design requires
no more than 15.2 x 5.7 mm of space and
ensures a VSWR ratio of less than 2
across the 2.4 GHz ISM band when
connected to a 50 ohm source.

Figure 1: CC2511 USB Dongle
SWRA117D Page 1 of 21

Application Note AN043

Table of Contents

1 KEYWO RDS ……………………………………………………………………………………………………. 1
2 INTRODUCT ION………………………………………………………………………………………………. 1
3 ABBREVIATIO NS…………………………………………………………………………………………….. 2
4 ANTENNA D ESIGN ………………………………………………………………………………………….. 3
4.1 DESIG N GOALS……………………………………………………………………………………………. 3
4.2 SIMULATION ………………………………………………………………………………………………… 3
4.3 LAYOUT AND IMPLEMENTATION ……………………………………………………………………….. 4
5 TEST R ESULTS ………………………………………………………………………………………………. 5
5.1 REFLECTIO N……………………………………………………………………………………………….. 5
5.2 RADIATIO N PATTERN …………………………………………………………………………………….. 7
5.3 OUTPUT POWER………………………………………………………………………………………… 15
5.4 SPURIOUS EMISSIO N AND HARMONICS ……………………………………………………………. 17
6 CONCLUSIO N……………………………………………………………………………………………….. 20
7 GENERAL INFO RMATION ……………………………………………………………………………… 21
7.1 DOCUMENT HISTORY …………………………………………………………………………………… 21

3 ABBREVIATIONS

CAD Computer Aided Design
CC24xx CC2400, CC2420, CC2430 and CC2431
CC25xx CC2500, CC2510, CC2511, CC2550 and CC2520
CC2480 Z-Accel ZigBee Processor
IFA Inverted F Antenna
ISM Industrial, Scientific and Medical
LOS Line Of Sight
PCB Printed Circuit Board
PER Pac ket Error Rate
VSWR Voltage Standing Wave Ratio

SWRA117D Page 2 of 21

Application Note AN043

4 ANTENNA DESIGN
The PCB antenna on the CC2511 USB dongle reference design is a meandered Inverted F
Antenna (IFA). The IFA was designed to matc h an impedance of 50 ohm at 2.45 GHz. Thus
no additional matching components are necessary.

4.1 Design Goals
The reflection at the feed point of the antenna determines how much of the applied power is
delivered to the antenna. A reflection of less than -10 dB across the 2.4 GHz ISM band, when
connected to a 50 ohm source, was a design goal . Reflection of less than -10 dB, or VSWR
less than 2, ensures that more than 90% of the available pow er is delivered to the antenna.
Bandwidth is in this document defined as the frequency band where more than 90% of the
available power is delivered to the antenna. Another design goal was to fit the size of the PCB
antenna on a USB dongle and to obtain good performance also when the dongle is
connected to a computer.

4.2 Simulation
IE3D from Zeland, which is an electromagnet ic simulation tool, was used to design the
antenna. The accuracy of the simulation is cont rolled by the mesh. An increase of the mesh
increases the simulation time. Thus, for initial simulations mesh = 1 should be used. When a
fairly good result is achieved a higher mesh s hould be used to obtain more accurate results.
Comparison of simulation and measurement results shows that the measured reflection is
between the result obtained with mesh = 5 and mesh = 1; see Figure 2 for details.

Figure 2: Comparison of Simulation and Measurements Results
SWRA117D Page 3 of 21

Application Note AN043

4.3 Layout and Implementation
Small changes of the antenna dimensions may have large impact on the performance.
Therefore it is strongly recommended to make an exact copy of the reference design to
achieve optimum performance. The easiest wa y to implement the antenna is to import the
gerber or DXF file showing the antenna lay out. These files are named IFA_USB.spl and
IFA_USB.dxf respectively and are included in the CC2511 USB dongle reference design
available from http://www.ti.c om\lpw . The imported file can be used as a template when
drawing the antenna. By using this procedure it should be possible to make an exact copy. If
the PCB CAD tool being used does not s upport import of DXF or gerber files, Figure 3 and
Table 1 should be used to ensure correct im plementation. It is recommended to generate a
gerber file for comparison with IFA_USB.sp l when making a manual implementation. Most
gerber viewers have the possibility to import seve ral gerber files at the same time. Thus by
placing the gerber file, showing the manually implemented antenna, on top of IFA_USB.spl it
is easy to verify that the antenna is correctly implemented. It is also recommended to use the
same thickness and type of PCB material as us ed in the reference design. Information about
the PCB can be found in a separate readme f ile included in the reference design. To
compensate for a thicker/thinner PCB the antenna could be made slightly shorter/longer.

Figure 3: Antenna Dimensions

L1 3.94 mm
L2 2.70 mm
L3 5.00 mm
L4 2.64 mm
L5 2.00 mm
L6 4.90 mm
W1 0.90 mm
W2 0.50 mm
D1 0.50 mm
D2 0.30 mm
D3 0.30 mm
D4 0.50 mm
D5 1.40mm
D6 1.70 mm
Table 1: Antenna Dimensions
SWRA117D Page 4 of 21

Application Note AN043

5 TEST RESULTS
Reflection, radiation pattern and variation of output power across a wide frequency band were
measured to verify the performance of the PCB antenna. Measurements of the dongle in free
space and when connected to a laptop were perfo rmed to verify that the antenna is suitable
both for USB dongle designs and in a standalone applic ation. Free space is in this document
interpreted as a measurement performed wit hout connecting the dongle to a computer. In
such a measurement the dongle is only powered by a battery.

5.1 Reflection
All the reflection measurements were perform ed with a network analyzer connected to a
semi-rigid coax cable, which was soldered to the feed point of the antenna. Because of the
small size antenna and the small ground plane this kind of measurements is heavily affected
by the presence and placement of the coax cable. This influence can result in a small
uncertainty in resonance frequency and measured refl ection. Typically different placement of
the semi-rigid coax cable could change t he resonance frequency with 5 -10 MHz and the
reflection with 3 – 4 dB.

Figure 4: Influence of Plastic Encapsulation and Test Pins

SWRA117D Page 5 of 21

Application Note AN043

A small part on the CC2511 USB dongle PCB is equipped with test pins. These are intended
for use during development. This part of the PCB w ill typically be omitted in a final application.
The red and green graph on Figure 4 shows that removing this part of the PCB has a small
impact on the performance. Figure 4 also shows that plastic encapsulation of the dongle will
shift the resonance frequency to a lower frequenc y. This can be compensated by making the
antenna slightly shorter.

The size of the ground plane affects the performance of the PCB antenna. Connecting the
USB dongle to a computer increases the size of the ground plane and thus the performance
is affected. Figure 5 shows how the perfo rmance is affected when the USB dongle is
connected to a laptop. In free space the ant enna has a bandwidth of approximately 250 MHz.
When the USB dongle is connected to the l aptop the bandwidth is reduced to around 100
MHz, which still is enough to cover the whole 2.4 GHz ISM band.

Figure 5: Comparison of Performance
SWRA117D Page 6 of 21

Application Note AN043

5.2 Radiation Pattern
The radiation pattern for the antenna implemented on the CC2511 USB dongle reference
design has been measured in an anechoic c hamber. Figure 7 through Figure 12 shows
radiation patterns for three planes, XY, XZ and YZ, measured with vertical and horizontal
polarization. All these measurement were performed without connecting the dongle to a
computer. Figure 13 and Figure 14 shows the r adiation pattern when the dongle is connected
to a laptop. All measurements were performed with 0 dBm output power. Figure 6 shows how
the different radiation patters are re lated to the positioning of the antenna.

XY plane

YZ plane

XZ plane
Figure 6: How to Relate the Antenna to the Radiation Patterns

SWRA117D Page 7 of 21

Application Note AN043

Figure 7: USB Dongle XY Plane
SWRA117D Page 8 of 21

Application Note AN043

Figure 8: USB Dongle XY Plane
SWRA117D Page 9 of 21

Application Note AN043

Figure 9: USB Dongle XZ Plane
SWRA117D Page 10 of 21

Application Note AN043

Figure 10: USB Dongle XZ Plane
SWRA117D Page 11 of 21

Application Note AN043

Figure 11: USB Dongle YZ Plane
SWRA117D Page 12 of 21

Application Note AN043

Figure 12: USB Dongle YZ Plane
SWRA117D Page 13 of 21

Application Note AN043

Figure 13: USB Dongle in Laptop XY Plane
SWRA117D Page 14 of 21

Application Note AN043

Figure 14: USB Dongle in Laptop XY Plane
5.3 Output Pow er
To make a realistic bandwidth measurement of the antenna a small test program was used.
The test program stepped the center frequency of a carrier from 2.3 to 2.8 GHz. This
bandwidth measurement was also done to verify t he result from the reflection measurements,
described in section 5.1. The output power was measured using max hold on a spectrum
analyzer. CC2511 was programmed for 0 dBm output power and the antenna was
horizontally oriented and directed towards the receiving antenna. This corresponds to 0° in
the XY plane on Figure 6. The bandwidth measurements were not performed with a
correction factor on the spectrum analyzer. T hus, the results in Figure 15 and Figure 16 only
show the relative changes in output power and not the actual level.

Figure 15 shows the bandwidth of the ant enna when the dongle is not connected to a
computer. The result shows that the antenna has a variation in output power of less than 3 dB
across a frequency band of more than 350 MHz. This demonstrates that the antenna has a
SWRA117D Page 15 of 21

Application Note AN043

broadband characteristic. Maximum output power is measured to be at 2.54 GHz. Thus if the
same antenna is implemented on a PCB with similar size and if the application is only
intended for stand alone usage the antenna could be made slightly longer to obtain best
performance at 2.42 GHz.

Figure 15: Output Pow er, USB Dongle

The reflection results in Figure 5 indicate t hat the output power will be slightly reduced when
the dongle is connected to a laptop. Comparis on of the results in Figure 15 and Figure 16
shows that the output power is reduced by approximately 2 dB when the dongle is connected
to a laptop. This agrees with the results in Figure 5.
SWRA117D Page 16 of 21

Application Note AN043

Figure 16: Output Pow er, USB Dongle in Laptop
5.4 Spurious Emission and Harmonics
Table 2 shows measured output power and emi ssion at the second har monic. Above the
second harmonic no peaks were detected when m easuring TX emission. This can be seen
from Figure 17 and Figure 18. These measurements were performed according to FCC
requirements. An approximate conversion to dBm can be done by subtracting 95 from the
measured value in dB µV/m. Since the measurement setup for ETSI and FCC is different this
conversion will not give an exact result, but typically it will give a result that is within 1-2 dB of
the result from a correct ETSI measurement.

Output power 2.44 GHz 4.88 GHz
1 dBm 96.9 dB µV/m 56.1 dBµV/m
0 dBm 96.1 dB µV/m 54.3 dBµV/m
-2 dBm 93.1 dB µV/m 52.5 dBµV/m
Table 2: Measured Lev el of Output Pow er and Harmonics

ETSI and FCC limits for output power and TX spur ious emission are shown in Table 3. FCC
allows for up to 20 dB higher emission if duty cyc ling is used. Thus, it is possible to use the
antenna described in this document and be compli ant with both ETSI and FCC regulation.
SWRA117D Page 17 of 21

Application Note AN043

EN 300 328 EN 300 440 FCC 15.247 FCC 15.249
2.4 – 2.483 GHz 20 dBm 10 dBm* 125 dBµV/m
116 dBµV/m** 94 dBµV/m
2. harm -30 dBm -30 dBm 54 dBµV/m 54 dBµV/m
*Depends on the power class.
** Depends on the number of channels being used.
Table 3: ETSI and FCC Limits

Figure 17: TX Spurious Emission 1 – 5 GHz
SWRA117D Page 18 of 21

Application Note AN043

Figure 18: TX Spurious Emission 5.5 – 8.5 GHz
As opposed to FCC, ETSI has specific RX em ission requirements. Table 4 and Table 5 list
the ETSI RX spurious requirements.

Narrowband spurious emission Wideband spurious emission
30 MHz to 1 GHz -57 dBm -107 dBm/Hz
1 GHz to 12.75 GHz -47 dBm -97 dBm/Hz
Table 4: EN 300 328 RX Spurious Requirements

25 MHz to 1 GHz -57 dBm
1 GHz to 10 times the carrier frequency* -47 dBm
*Applies for equipment operating between 1 GHz and 20 GHz.
Table 5: EN 300 440 RX Spurious Requirements

The only signal detected above the noise floor when measuring RX spurious emission was
the VCO leakage at 4.89 GHz. Figure 19 show s that the measured VCO leakage is below
ETSI limits.
SWRA117D Page 19 of 21

Application Note AN043

Figure 19: RX Spurious Emission

6 CONCLUSION
This application note shows that it is possi ble to implement a 2.4 GHz antenna on a small
area and still achieve good performance. Table 6 lists the most important properties of the
Inverted F Antenna, described in this docum ent. The free line of sight (LOS) range was
measured with 250 kbps and 1 % PER.

Gain in XY plane 4.5 dB
Gain in XZ plane 5.3 dB
Gain in YZ plane 5.3 dB
Gain in XY plane, connected to laptop 3.3 dB
LOS range 240 m
Antenna size 15.2 x 5.7 mm
Table 6: IFA Properties (Measured on CC2511 Dongle Reference Design)

The results provided in section 5 shows that it is possible to comply with both ETSI and FCC
regulations when implementing the sugges ted antenna together with CC2511 on a USB
dongle.
SWRA117D Page 20 of 21

Application Note AN043

7 GENERAL INFORMATION
7.1 Document History
Revision Date Description/Changes
SWRA117D 2008-04-04 Changed CCZACC06 to CC2480
SWRA117C 2008-02-27 Added reference to CCZACC06 and CC2520
SWRA117B 2007-06-01 Changed name of document
SWRA117A 2007-01-08 Added more dimens ions in Figure 3 and Table 1
SWRA117 2006-11-28 Initial release.

SWRA117D Page 21 of 21

IMPORTANT
NOTICE
Texas
Instruments
Incorporated
and
its
subsidiaries
(TI)
reserve
the
right
to
make
corrections,
modifications,
enhancements,
improvements,
and
other
changes
to
its
products
and
services
at
any
time
and
to
discontinue
any
product
or
service
without
notice.
Customers
should
obtain
the
latest
relevant
information
before
placing
orders
and
should
verify
that
such
information
is
current
and
complete.
All
products
are
sold
subject
to
TI
’
s
terms
and
conditions
of
sale
supplied
at
the
time
of
order
acknowledgment.
TI
warrants
performance
of
its
hardware
products
to
the
specifications
applicable
at
the
time
of
sale
in
accordance
with
TI
’
s
standard
warranty.
Testing
and
other
quality
control
techniques
are
used
to
the
extent
TI
deems
necessary
to
support
this
warranty.
Except
where
mandated
by
government
requirements,
testing
of
all
parameters
of
each
product
is
not
necessarily
performed.
TI
assumes
no
liability
for
applications
assistance
or
customer
product
design.
Customers
are
responsible
for
their
products
and
applications
using
TI
components.
To
minimize
the
risks
associated
with
customer
products
and
applications,
customers
should
provide
adequate
design
and
operating
safeguards.
TI
does
not
warrant
or
represent
that
any
license,
either
express
or
implied,
is
granted
under
any
TI
patent
right,
copyright,
mask
work
right,
or
other
TI
intellectual
property
right
relating
to
any
combination,
machine,
or
process
in
which
TI
products
or
services
are
used.
Information
published
by
TI
regarding
third-party
products
or
services
does
not
constitute
a
license
from
TI
to
use
such
products
or
services
or
a
warranty
or
endorsement
thereof.
Use
of
such
information
may
require
a
license
from
a
third
party
under
the
patents
or
other
intellectual
property
of
the
third
party,
or
a
license
from
TI
under
the
patents
or
other
intellectual
property
of
TI.
Reproduction
of
TI
information
in
TI
data
books
or
data
sheets
is
permissible
only
if
reproduction
is
without
alteration
and
is
accompanied
by
all
associated
warranties,
conditions,
limitations,
and
notices.
Reproduction
of
this
information
with
alteration
is
an
unfair
and
deceptive
business
practice.
TI
is
not
responsible
or
liable
for
such
altered
documentation.
Information
of
third
parties
may
be
subject
to
additional
restrictions.
Resale
of
TI
products
or
services
with
statements
different
from
or
beyond
the
parameters
stated
by
TI
for
that
product
or
service
voids
all
express
and
any
implied
warranties
for
the
associated
TI
product
or
service
and
is
an
unfair
and
deceptive
business
practice.
TI
is
not
responsible
or
liable
for
any
such
statements.
TI
products
are
not
authorized
for
use
in
safety-critical
applications
(such
as
life
support)
where
a
failure
of
the
TI
product
would
reasonably
be
expected
to
cause
severe
personal
injury
or
death,
unless
officers
of
the
parties
have
executed
an
agreement
specifically
governing
such
use.
Buyers
represent
that
they
have
all
necessary
expertise
in
the
safety
and
regulatory
ramifications
of
their
applications,
and
acknowledge
and
agree
that
they
are
solely
responsible
for
all
legal,
regulatory
and
safety-related
requirements
concerning
their
products
and
any
use
of
TI
products
in
such
safety-critical
applications,
notwithstanding
any
applications-related
information
or
support
that
may
be
provided
by
TI.
Further,
Buyers
must
fully
indemnify
TI
and
its
representatives
against
any
damages
arising
out
of
the
use
of
TI
products
in
such
safety-critical
applications.
TI
products
are
neither
designed
nor
intended
for
use
in
military/aerospace
applications
or
environments
unless
the
TI
products
are
specifically
designated
by
TI
as
military-grade
or
"enhanced
plastic."
Only
products
designated
by
TI
as
military-grade
meet
military
specifications.
Buyers
acknowledge
and
agree
that
any
such
use
of
TI
products
which
TI
has
not
designated
as
military-grade
is
solely
at
the
Buyer's
risk,
and
that
they
are
solely
responsible
for
compliance
with
all
legal
and
regulatory
requirements
in
connection
with
such
use.
TI
products
are
neither
designed
nor
intended
for
use
in
automotive
applications
or
environments
unless
the
specific
TI
products
are
designated
by
TI
as
compliant
with
ISO/TS
16949
requirements.
Buyers
acknowledge
and
agree
that,
if
they
use
any
non-designated
products
in
automotive
applications,
TI
will
not
be
responsible
for
any
failure
to
meet
such
requirements.
Following
are
URLs
where
you
can
obtain
information
on
other
Texas
Instruments
products
and
application
solutions:
Products
Applications
Amplifiers
amplifier.ti.com
Audio
www.ti.com/audio
Data
Converters
dataconverter.ti.com
Automotive
www.ti.com/automotive
DSP
dsp.ti.com
Broadband
www.ti.com/broadband
Clocks
and
Timers
www.ti.com/clocks
Digital
Control
www.ti.com/digitalcontrol
Interface
interface.ti.com
Medical
www.ti.com/medical
Logic
logic.ti.com
Military
www.ti.com/military
Power
Mgmt
power.ti.com
Optical
Networking
www.ti.com/opticalnetwork
Microcontrollers
microcontroller.ti.com
Security
www.ti.com/security
RFID
www.ti-rfid.com
Telephony
www.ti.com/telephony
RF/IF
and
ZigBee
®
Solutions
www.ti.com/lprf
Video
&
Imaging
www.ti.com/video
Wireless
www.ti.com/wireless
Mailing
Address:
Texas
Instruments,
Post
Office
Box
655303,
Dallas,
Texas
75265
Copyright
©
2008,
Texas
Instruments
Incorporated